Farhy v. Commr. – The Penalty for Failing to Timely File Form 5471 May Not Be Assessed Administratively

Volume 10 No 3    /    Read Article

By Stanley C. Ruchelman and Wooyoung Lee

Sometimes, good things happen to the undeserving. In the play “Pygmalion,” Alfred Doolittle – the undeserving father of Eliza Doolittle – receives a bequest from a faraway benefactor. In Farhy v. Commr., a scofflaw who refused to file Form 5471 for several Belize companies and received penalty notices regarding the seizure of his property convinced the Tax Court that the penalty was not self-enforcing. Rather, the Department of Justice would be required to initiate enforcement proceedings in District Court to collect the assessed penalties. Stanley C. Ruchelman and Wooyoung Lee explain the reasoning of the decision and then ask which other penalties have similar requirements. In answer, they survey client alerts published on the internet by various firms. Surprisingly, the answers are not consistent.  See more →