HIDE

Other Publications

Insights

Publications

Tax Cases Affecting Remote Workers and Their Employers

Tax Cases Affecting Remote Workers and Their Employers

The legacy of the pandemic has demonstrated that an employee does not need to be in the office in order to work efficiently. Employees have adjusted to working remotely. In North America, remote working may mean a location in the suburbs surrounding the location of a business office, or perhaps a nearby state. In Europe, remote working may mean relocation to a different country. This raises questions for the employer regarding to the establishment of a P.E. in the country where the employee resides. Sunita Doobay, a partner of Blainey McMurtry, L.L.P., Toronto, discusses two recent tax rulings in Denmark and Spain and one tax case in Finland that address the issue. While all acknowledge that facts control the decision, tax administrations do not exercise judgement consistently.

Read More

Adventures in Cross-Border Tax Collection: Revenue Rule vs. Cum-Ex Litigation

Published in Tax Notes Federal Volume 175, No. 3 & Tax Notes International Volume 106, No. 3: April 18, 2022. Copyright © 2022, Sunita Doobay and Stanley C. Ruchelman.

Read More

Collecting Another Country’s Taxes – Recent Experience in the Canada-U.S. Context

Collecting Another Country’s Taxes – Recent Experience in the Canada-U.S. Context

In an age of multilateral agreements to exchange information and other agreements to cooperate in the collection of taxes of another country, many people are unaware of the “revenue rule.” This common law doctrine allows courts to decline entertaining suits to collect tax or enforce foreign tax judgments. In their article, Sunita Doobay of Blaney McMurtry L.L.P., Toronto, and Stanley C. Ruchelman explore (i) the general development of the revenue rule, (ii) its extension to North America, (iii) the applicable provisions of the Canada-U.S. Income Tax Treaty allowing for assistance in the collection of tax and exchange of information, (iv) one U.S. wire fraud case involving evasion of foreign import duties, and (v) several recent cases in the U.S. where taxpayers raised creative arguments to attack the validity of treaty provisions, but to no avail.

Read More

Can Tax Authorities Demand Access to Audit Workpapers? Canadian Experience Follows U.S. Rule

Can Tax Authorities Demand Access to Audit Workpapers? Canadian Experience Follows U.S. Rule

Recent victories in litigation have allowed the Canada Revenue Agency to review tax accrual workpapers of Canadian corporations, provided the request for access is not a “fishing expedition” attempting to find issues.In the U.S., the I.R.S. has enjoyed that power for many years. Sunita Doobay of Blaney McMurtry L.L.P., Toronto, examines the scope and limitations of the Canadian decisions. Stanley C. Ruchelman reviews case law in the U.S., the role of FIN 48, and the purpose behind Schedule UTP (reporting uncertain tax positions), which surprisingly is designed to limit examinations of tax accrual workpapers.

Read More